Home › Resources › 99% of EHCP Appeals Succeed

99% of EHCP Appeals
Succeed at Tribunal

Here's what that tells you about the “no” you've just received — and what actually changes the outcome.

If your council has just refused to assess your child, refused to issue an EHCP, or issued a plan that doesn't reflect what your child actually needs, there's a number worth knowing before you decide what to do next. Of the EHCP appeals that reached a tribunal decision in 2024/25, 99% were decided in favour of the family. Not a slim majority. Not most. Almost all of them.

Want to talk this through? The first 15-minute call is free.

Book a free call →

That figure doesn't mean an appeal is a formality — and we'll come to what it genuinely does and doesn't tell you. But it does mean something uncomfortable and important: when these disagreements are actually tested by an independent panel, the council's original decision is very often found to be wrong.

The numbers

99%

The proportion of EHCP appeals decided at the SEND Tribunal in 2024/25 that went in favour of the appellant — almost always the parent or young person. The same proportion as the year before. Source: Ministry of Justice, Tribunal Statistics Quarterly, SEN appeals, academic year 2024/25.

This isn't a one-year blip, and it isn't getting better. The Institute for Fiscal Studies tracked the same measure back through the decade: the success rate has climbed from 93.9% in 2016/17 to 99.2% in 2024/25.

Meanwhile the volume has exploded. Appeals registered with the tribunal reached 25,000 in 2024/25 — up 18% in a single year, and the ninth consecutive annual increase. In 2018/19 the figure was 7,000. Appeals are now being lodged faster than they can be resolved, and the open caseload hit a record 15,000.

What families are actually appealing. Around three in five appeals concern what a plan says — how a child's needs are described, what support is promised, and which school is named. Roughly a quarter are against a council's refusal to assess in the first place. The rest cover refusals to issue a plan, decisions to stop maintaining one, and other grounds.
One important distinction. These figures cover EHCP appeals — refusals to assess, refusals to issue a plan, the content of a plan, and decisions to cease maintaining one. The SEND Tribunal also hears disability discrimination claims against schools under the Equality Act, which are counted separately and have a very different success rate: historically only around a third are upheld. The 99% applies to EHCP appeals, not to every case the Tribunal hears.

What the 99% does — and doesn't — mean

This is where it's worth being precise, because the figure is easy to over-read.

  • It describes appeals that reached a decision. Cases that got as far as a tribunal ruling. It isn't a prediction that any given appeal will succeed regardless of merit.
  • “In the family's favour” means winning the majority of the appeal — not necessarily every point argued.
  • Placement disputes are genuinely harder. Where the argument is specifically about which school is named, around 13% of decisions went to the local authority's preferred option. Parents still succeeded in more than half — but this is the area where councils win most often.
  • Many appeals never reach a hearing at all. A significant proportion are conceded or settled by the council beforehand — which is its own kind of answer about the strength of the original decision.

Read carefully, the 99% isn't really a statistic about tribunals. It's a statistic about the quality of the decisions being appealed.

Why councils keep refusing anyway

The obvious question: if local authorities lose almost every time, why do they keep saying no?

Part of the answer is straightforward financial pressure. High needs budgets are under severe strain, and every assessment agreed, every plan issued, and every specialist placement named carries cost. Part of it is process — refusals at the assessment stage are cheaper and faster to issue than assessments are to carry out.

And part of it, honestly, is that most refusals are never challenged. Only a fraction of families appeal. A refusal that goes unappealed is, from a purely budgetary standpoint, a refusal that worked. The 99% figure only describes the families who pushed back.

If you've had a refusal letter, the most useful thing to know is this: a “no” from a local authority is not a neutral assessment of your child's needs. It's one decision, made under significant financial pressure, that an independent panel overturns in the overwhelming majority of cases where it's actually examined.

What actually changes the outcome: evidence

Here's the part that matters practically, and it's consistent across everything the data shows.

Tribunals don't decide these cases on how strongly a parent feels, or on how well they present on the day. They decide on whether there is clear, credible, current evidence of what a child needs — and whether the provision on offer meets it. Where councils do successfully defend placement decisions, it's because they've been able to justify them with evidence about suitability, cost-effectiveness and how the provision meets the needs set out in the plan.

The same logic runs in reverse. A family arriving with an up-to-date, independent, specific picture of their child — the academic gaps, the cognitive profile, the processing difficulties, the barriers to learning — is in a completely different position to a family arriving with a diagnosis letter and a strong conviction.

Been refused an assessment or issued a plan that doesn't match your child? A free 15-minute call is a calm place to talk through what evidence would strengthen your position.

Book a free 15-minute call
Education With Lauren

Where Education With Lauren fits in

We don't run appeals and we don't represent families at tribunal — for that, IPSEA and IASK (Information, Advice and Support Kent, 03000 41 3000) both offer free, independent advice and support, and we'd always point you there first.

What we do is the part that comes before: building the independent, evidenced picture of your child that an appeal, an application, or a conversation with school actually turns on.

  • The Achieving & Thriving Gap Analysis — a clear, current, independent picture of academic attainment, cognitive profile, processing, sensory and behavioural needs, produced in a form designed to be used as evidence.
  • Private EHCP Reports — detailed reports written to support a request for an EHC needs assessment, which families submit themselves.
  • Tailored Education Support — including reports for EHCP appeals and tribunal, and support with local authority correspondence and meetings.
★★★★★

“The detail and advice that Lauren provides in her report goes above and beyond.”

Georgina · Google review
★★★★★

“Not only did she spot things that were constantly being brushed off as ‘normal’ — she listened to me as a parent. My child is struggling and Lauren sees straight through the mask.”

Tara · Google review
A refusal letter tells you what one council decided under budget pressure. It doesn't tell you what your child needs. Only evidence does that.
Explore EHCP & Evidence Support

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of EHCP appeals are successful?

Of the EHCP appeals decided by the SEND Tribunal in 2024/25, 99% were decided in favour of the appellant, almost always the parent or young person. This is the same proportion as the previous year, and the figure has risen from 93.9% in 2016/17.

Does that mean my appeal will definitely succeed?

No. The figure describes appeals that reached a tribunal decision, and 'in the family's favour' means winning the majority of an appeal rather than every point. Placement-specific disputes are harder, with around 13% of those decisions going to the local authority's preferred option. Appeals still turn on the quality of the evidence.

How many EHCP appeals are there each year?

Around 25,000 appeals were registered in 2024/25, an 18% rise on the previous year and the ninth consecutive annual increase, up from 7,000 in 2018/19.

What can I appeal?

Decisions carrying a right of appeal include a refusal to carry out an EHC needs assessment, a refusal to issue a plan, the content of a plan (which can be appealed section by section), and a decision to cease maintaining a plan.

Who can help me with an EHCP appeal?

IPSEA and your local SEND Information, Advice and Support Service (SENDIASS; in Kent, IASK) offer free, independent advice. Education With Lauren provides independent assessment evidence but does not run appeals or represent families at SEND Tribunal.

This article is general information about published tribunal statistics, not legal advice. Education With Lauren does not run appeals or represent families at SEND Tribunal. For advice on your own situation, contact IPSEA or your local SENDIASS.

Sources

  • Ministry of Justice, Tribunal Statistics Quarterly (July to September 2025), SEN appeals, academic year 2024/25
  • Institute for Fiscal Studies, analysis of tribunal appeal volumes and success rates, July 2026
  • Tes, “SEND appeals hit new record high,” December 2025
  • Browne Jacobson, SEND Tribunal data analysis, January 2026
  • IPSEA (ipsea.org.uk) · Information, Advice and Support Kent (IASK)

“A refusal letter tells you what one council decided. It doesn't tell you what your child needs.”

Build the evidence behind your case

Not sure where to start?

A free 15-minute call comes first.

We’ll tell you honestly whether we can help.

Book your free 15-minute call

We’ll call or email to arrange a time that suits you.

No cost and no obligation. By submitting this form you agree to be contacted by Education With Lauren regarding your enquiry. Your data is handled in line with our Privacy Policy.